The life cycles of these insects contribute to their importance as trout table fare. It is common for the species to have two and sometimes three generations in a single year. The number of generations is largely determined by water temperature. Cold, high elevation or more northerly streams may produce only two generations a year, while slightly warmer streams at lower elevations or further south often produce three generations a year. Spring creeks with relatively constant water temperatures can have Baetis hatches almost every month of the year.
Variations in the size and color of BWOs occur in the same species and in the same region from stream to stream. As a matter of fact, they look more like grey winged olives. They prefer to hatch on cool, rainy, and overcast days.
Like most Mayflies, BWOs swim to the surface, break free of their nymphal shell and emerge on the rivers’ surface as an adult. At this point they drift on the surface while their wings dry. The warmer the weather, the less time they spend on the surface which makes it more difficult for the trout.
The nymph, emerger, and dun stages are the most important to fly fishers. Spinners are generally not a factor since many females of the species crawl down into the water from a rock to lay eggs.
Some of the best fishing I've ever encountered was on the Bighorn in early April during a snowstorm. On one memorable day the hatch lasted for 6 hours. It seemed as though every fish in the river (as far as I could see) was rising to size 18 duns.
While the range of patterns for BWOs is astonishing,
many of the characteristics of the better flies have similarities.
--Olive to olive-grey bodies
--Beefy thorax
--Small sizes with 16 to 22 being the norm
--Predominance of CDC and dun colored saddle
--Use of synthetics for tailing
Day in and day out I believe emergers fished in the
surface film will out-catch any other creation.